Battle of the Soaps: Goat Milk Soap vs Castile

Ding, ding, ding! Welcome back for another round of the battle of the soaps. In today’s match-up, we will be looking at goat milk soap vs. castile soap. Who do you think will win?

Let’s dive into the similarities and differences between goat milk soap vs. castile soap, but first, we’ll review what goat milk soap and castile soap are for those who aren’t familiar.

goat milk soap vs castile

What Is Goat Milk Soap?

Goat milk soap is a type of soap containing natural ingredients including goat’s milk. It is made using a traditional saponification process that combines ingredients including oils and goat’s milk into an effective, creamy, and nourishing bar of soap.

What is Castile Soap?

Castile soap is a type of soap that is made from vegetable oils. It originated in the Castile region of Spain, which is of course where it gets its name, and has been produced for centuries. Traditionally, it is made from olive oil though several variations exist these days.

goat milk soap vs castile

Similarities of Goat Milk Soap vs. Castile Soap

There are two main similarities between goat milk soap and castile soap besides the fact they are indeed both soap.

Both Natural Products & Biodegradable

Both goat milk soap and castile soap are natural soaps that utilize all-natural ingredients making them both quite popular for those who prefer natural skin care products. Neither includes artificial synthetic fragrances, colors, and preservatives. This also makes both goat soap and castile soap eco-friendly and biodegradable.

Both Are Effective Cleansers

In addition to both soaps being comprised of natural ingredients, goat milk soap and castile soap are both effective cleansers as well. They both remove dirt and bacteria really well while still remaining gentle on the skin.

Differences between Goat Milk Soap vs. Castile Soap

Right now you are probably on the fence about goat milk soap vs castile soap. Despite having two good similarities, the differences between the two are probably where you will make a decision about which you think is better.

Ingredients

Both goat milk soap and castile soap may be natural soaps, but they still have different ingredients. Goat milk soap contains goat’s milk, natural oils, and often essential oils for scenting. Castile soap, on the other hand, is made with olive oil and water, and sometimes other vegetable oils, such as coconut or jojoba oil. Though there might be some overlap on a few of the added oils, the bases of goat milk soap and castile soap are different.

Vegan-Friendly

Another difference between goat milk soap and castile soap is that goat milk soap is made with an animal product (goat’s milk), whereas castile soap only contains oils and ingredients derived from vegetables. This means that castile soap is vegan-friendly, while goat milk soap is not.

Benefits

In terms of benefits, both goat milk soap and Castile soap can effectively cleanse the skin, but goat milk soap may provide additional moisturizing and skin-soothing benefits due to the presence of natural moisturizers and vitamins in goat milk. Castile soap may be more suitable for those with very sensitive skin or those who prefer a soap with minimal ingredients. Castile soap is also the better choice for those following a vegan lifestyle.

goat milk soap vs castile

Goat Milk Soap vs. Castile Soap: Who is the Winner?

So now that we have gone over the similarities and differences between goat milk soap vs. castile soap, it is time to crown a winner. Who do you think wins this round of the battle of the soaps?

Some would choose goat milk soap for its skin-nourishing natural moisturizers, though others would side with castile soap due to being vegan-friendly. Are you going to try castile soap, GOAT Soap, or both?