Battle of the Soaps: Goat Milk Soap vs Dove

Ding, ding, ding! It is time again for the battle of the soaps. In today’s match-up, we will be looking at goat milk soap vs. Dove soap. Who do you think will win?

Let’s dive into the similarities and differences between goat milk soap vs. Dove soap, but first, we’ll review what goat milk soap is for those who aren’t familiar.

goat milk soap vs dove

What is Goat Milk Soap?

Goat milk soap is a type of soap that is made with goat's milk instead of water or other liquids. The milk used in goat milk soap is typically fresh or powdered goat milk, which is added to the soap mixture during the traditional soap making process of saponification.

Similarities of Goat Milk Soap vs. Dove

Goat milk soap and Dove soap have only two major similarities.

Both Have Cleansing Properties

For one, they are both soaps, so they both have cleansing properties that remove dirt and bacteria. Of course, when you are buying soap, this is essential! It is worth noting that while they both have effective cleansing properties, goat milk soap tends to be a more gentle cleanser on the skin.

Both Are Similar in Price

The second similarity is that both goat milk soap and Dove soap tend to be around the same price. Many people think that all-natural products are more expensive, but there actually isn’t a huge cost difference between the two.

goat milk soap vs dove

Differences Between Goat Milk Soap vs. Dove

Goat milk soap and Dove soap are both types of soap and are both around the same price, but they have some differences in their composition, potential benefits, and scents among other things.


Goat milk soap is made from goat milk, which contains natural lactic acid and vitamins that can help soothe and moisturize the skin. Goat milk soap is also typically made with natural oils and essential oils. Dove soap, on the other hand, is a commercial bar soap that is formulated with synthetic ingredients such as sodium lauryl sulfate and fragrance.


Goat milk soap contains natural lactic acid and vitamins that can help soothe and moisturize the skin. Goat's milk is rich in vitamins and minerals, such as vitamin A, vitamin D, calcium, and potassium, and contains a higher fat and protein content which contribute to goat milk soap’s nourishing properties. While Dove soap is designed to be moisturizing, it may contain some chemicals that can irritate sensitive skin.

Goat milk soap may be more beneficial for those with dry skin, sensitive skin, or skin conditions like rosacea or eczema. It is believed to be gentle and mild on the skin since goat’s milk soap features a more similar pH to human skin than other soaps. Dove soap may be more suitable for those who prefer a more traditional bar soap with a pleasant scent.


Speaking of scents, while both goat milk soap and Dove soap can smell great, the scents you’ll find in each type of soap are different. This is because most goat milk soap is made with essential oils which are derived from things found in nature.

Dove soap is scented with fragrance oils which can be designed in a lab to smell like anything. Therefore, the scents of goat milk soap and Dove soap tend to be quite different. Goat milk soap tends to have a lighter, more natural smell, while Dove soap tends to have more strong, perfume-like scents.

Liquid vs. Bar Soap

Another difference is that Dove soap is available in both liquid soap and bar soap. Goat milk soap is often only found in bar form. This can be a pro or a con depending on your thoughts about bar soap.

goat milk soap vs dove

Goat Milk Soap vs Dove: Who’s The Winner?

So now that we have covered the similarities and differences, who do you think is the winner? Though some might say goat milk soap has more benefits and wins the battle, others have a preference for Dove. Really, the winner is decided by you. Will you try GOAT Soap or are you on team Dove?